Company Overview


We are proud to be an active
partner with the communities we serve!

Key Agency, Inc. is a four generation owned insurance agency, founded in 1952 by George Dignam. George was joined by his son, Tom, in 1962, when they built their first office on Manasota Key, at Beach Road. After ten great years on the beach, Key Agency needed a larger location and built their current Corporate Headquarters on McCall Road (SR776).

Key Agency is known regionally for being very community minded by supporting education, youth and adult sports, the arts, environmental causes and assisting our community’s most needy individuals. The management at Key Agency encourages their staff to be active in the community, and many are, whether it is serving on a committee, board, volunteering at charity events or assisting with fundraisers.

Each year, Key Agency and the Dignam family donate thousands of dollars to various not-for-profit groups, as well as giving thousands in educational scholarships to those who want to further their education at college, a trade school or vocational level. It is a true philosophy of giving that is practiced at Key Agency each day.

The staff at Key Agency is proud to be recognized as outstanding insurance professionals, whether for auto, home, life, business or health insurance. Key Agency stands ready to serve you with prompt and professional care, for all your insurance needs. With four area offices, and over 40 staff members, we are committed to protect what is valuable to you and your family.

We thank you for choosing Key Agency, Inc., since 1952.


David M. Dignam, Owner/Agent, President

Commercial Lines

Eric Fogo, Exec. V.P., Owner/Agent, Englewood

Beth Tubbesing, Producer/Agent, Englewood

Kandie Fogo, Agent, Englewood

Lisa Brumbaugh, Agent, Englewood

Sarah Wetzler, CSR, Englewood

Samantha Hawkins, Agent, Englewood

Theresa Reynolds, Agent, Englewood

Ann Foster-Speid, CSR, Englewood

Brian Blankenbaker, CSR, Englewood

Jeff Eldredge, Support, Englewood

Pat Lathrop, Processor, Englewood

Lyn Eastman, Agent, North Port

Krystal Stephens, CSR, North Port

Richard Schmith, Producer/Agent, North Port

Personal Lines

Brandon Dignam, Owner/Agent, Englewood

Janine Livesey, Agent, Boca Grande

Madison Johnson, CSR, Boca Grande

Austin Fogo, Agent, Englewood

Gail Strosnider, CSR, Englewood

Jennifer Krejci, Agent,/Realtor Concierge, Englewood

Laurie Wetzler, Agent, Englewood

Missy Johnivan, Agent, Englewood

Nicole Campbell, Agent, Englewood

Sandra Hayes, CSR, Englewood

Sarah Murtaugh, CSR, Englewood

Susan Deramo, Agent, Englewood

Taylor Wood, CSR, Englewood

Tyler Treasure, Agent, Englewood

Tina Watson, CSR, Englewood

Chace Schork CSR, Englewood

Bri Havens, CSR, Englewood

Becca Reagin, CSR, Englewood

Taylor Edwards, Processor/CSR Englewood

Susan Miller, Processor, Englewood

Lynn Willobee, Processor/CSR, Englewood

Kristine Riley, Processor, Englewood

Jodi Selph, CSR, North Port

Kim Nichols, Agent, North Port

Michael McGuinness, CSR, North Port

Nancy Ditsche, Receptionist/CSR, North Port

Cindy Brady, Receptionist, North Port


Sue Joachim, PCSR, Office Manager

Debra Konik, CSR, Supervisor

Chris Penney, Agent, Supervisor

Admin Personnel

Sheryl Downing, Administrative Asst.

Lori Uhl, Administrative Support

Janae Boyer, Receptionist/CSR


Cindy Lewis, Agent

Life, Health & Financial

David Wampler, Agent

Tonya Wampler, Agent

Jonathan Varner, Agent